Films broadcast without encryption during confinement: Canal + has ordered TF 1 to pay 1.5 million euros

Expensive gift In a decision of January 25, the Judicial Court of Paris has just ordered Canal + to pay more than 1.5 million euros to TF 1. In the case, the case comes from the first imposed confinement. Due to the Covid crisis. March 16, 2020 Maxime Saada, the head of Canal +, then announced a free-to-air switch to his pay-per-view channel, a sign of solidarity with millions of French people forced to stay locked at home. The decision was finalized two weeks later, on March 31, 2020.

During this time, many viewers were able to watch new films on TV without having to subscribe to Channel 4. This drew the ire of its free competitors, who sometimes paid dearly to be the first to offer unencrypted. Like TF 1, for example, it bet 1.8 million euros with the comedy “All Inclusive”. Franck Dubosc, or 4.5 million euros, for the American blockbuster “Avengers: Endgame”. » Two feature films offered by Canal+ in March 2020.

France Télévisions preferred to drop its proceedings

Believing that its competitor thus violated the chronology of the media, the subsidiary of the Bouygues group was criticized for getting the first broadcast window for free for airing 6 films. In April 2021, La Une took legal action, demanding more than 12 million euros from Canal + for “falsification” and “unfair competition”. » After also assigning the encrypted channel, French Televisions he preferred to drop his accusation. According to our information, the public company reached an agreement with its competitor in this matter at the end of last year.

After a hearing on September 26, TF 1 For his part, he has partially won his case. Rejecting the “forgery” accusation, the Paris court nevertheless ruled that the front page suffered a “loss of value of broadcasting rights” for three of the 6 films: the French comedies “All inclusive” and “So far so good”. “, as well as “Avengers: Endgame”. »

Canal + is considering the attraction

The unencrypted programming of the first two feature films will cost the encrypted channel almost 740,000 euros, and around 680,000 for the superhero movie with Robert Downey Jr. alone. To this amount of money is added the 100,000 euros given to the first page to compensate for moral damages. The channel, however, was denied other requests for compensation for broadcasts such as “Pokémon Detective Pikachu,” Godzilla 2 and “Crazy Rich Asians” because it was unable to produce their purchase agreement.

When contacted, the TF 1 team did not want to comment. For its part, Canal + says it is considering “appealing this judgment”.

Leave a comment